Cub Cadet XT3 GSX vs John Deere X500: Which One to Buy?

Having almost similar specs and features, people often get confused between XT3 and X500. In this Cub Cadet XT3 GSX vs John Deere X500 comparison, I will help you choose the best garden tractor.

Initially, seeing the price and engine power, one would say that Cub Cadet is the best option. But it won’t be wise to jump to such a conclusion quickly.

In this article, I have gathered some spec differences in these models, and done a comprehensive review. In the end, you will know which model is best suited for your tasks.

Cub Cadet XT3 GSX vs John Deere X500: Quick Comparison Table

I have gathered the comparison data in the table below to give you a clear overview.

What’s the Difference Between Cub Cadet XT3 GSX and John Deere X500 Based on Features?

As you have got an idea about the pros and cons of both models from the table above, I can explain things more easily in this part.

1. Engine Reliability

Both Cub Cadet and Kawasaki use engines from reputed manufacturers; Kohler and Kawasaki respectively.

When it comes to horsepower, you won’t see much difference in Cub Cadet XT3 GSX and John Deere X500.

But Kawasaki delivers the promised output, unlike Kohler. You can do your research and find out good things about accuracy in Kawasaki Engine ratings.

Now, I have read the reviews and feedback from the users. Almost everyone admits that Kawasaki offers more reliable performance with fewer issues compared to Kohler.

However, there is one parameter where Kohler wins; engine efficiency.

Kohler’s EFI technology makes their engine far less fuel consumption than competitors.

In this particular model of Cub Cadet garden tractor, they are using a carburetor engine. On the other hand, JD uses an EFI Kawasaki engine

Overall, the winner is Kawasaki. Hence, John Deere should be your mower of preference.

2. Fuel Delivery

You have already got an idea about the fuel delivery system of the concerned models in this article.

Cub Cadet uses a carburetor and John Deere uses EFI fuel delivery technology. In short, EFI is a more advanced and fuel-efficient system.

But carburetor engines are better in one segment; peak power. Carburetor engines are more reliable and need less maintenance.

Considering those factors, if fuel saving is not your primary concern, you can still consider John Deere as the winner.

3. Fuel Tank Capacity

With almost 4L more fuel tank capacity, John Deere has managed to hold its lead.

The benefit of a larger fuel tank is that you can cover larger yards with fewer stops. So, you can complete the whole task quicker than Cub Cadet.

But too big a fuel tank adds more weight, resulting in slower cutting performance. And, I don’t think it is the case here.

John Deere’s development team has researched to meet the sweet point where you get a longer runtime without compromising performance.

4. Speed

In terms of speed, Cub Cadet XT3 GSX is behind John Deere.

Both forward and reverse speeds in the JD X500 garden tractor are faster. On the other hand, speed doesn’t mean anything if the mower doesn’t have enough HP.

Considering everything, the JD garden tractor is a perfect combination of speed and power.

However, that doesn’t mean that Cub Cadet is bad. As I am comparing them, I have to keep one ahead of the other. And, JD is winning this battle.

5. Turning Radius

It seems that Cub Cadet has won 1 point over JD in this segment.

Due to having compact design, Cub Cadet XT3 GSX has a turning radius of only 18 inches. With almost similar dimensions, JD takes 22 inches to turn.

As a result, you can easily mow tight corners and around trees using XT3. Those who have to tackle such situations should buy Cub Cadet.

6. Battery Rating

Before I compare their prices, let me shine some light on a less significant matter.

I am saying less important because reviewers don’t focus on the battery rating much. But it is important for those who live in colder regions.

John Deere is offering a battery with a 500 CCA rating which is 200 more compared to Cub Cadet’s 300 CCA rating.

The benefit of a higher rating is that you can easily start the engine on a very cold morning without any problem.

Pro Tip: If you are going to buy Cub Cadet, make sure that you install a battery with higher CCA ratings for a cold start.

6. Price

If you go to the official website of John Deere, you will see 7 different models in the X500 series.

And, all of them are costlier than the Cub Cadet XT3 GSX garden tractor.

So, you can understand that budget is a big issue when you are choosing one from JD.

XT3 GSX costs around $6100 whereas John Deere X500 models start from around $6800 (X570).

The most expensive unit in this series is the X590 which costs around $8700.

Till now, seeing the feature comparisons above, you must have understood the reason for such high pricing.

7. Durability

Besides the engine, other parts of both tractor models are made from durable metals making them more durable than competitors.

Also, John Deere and Cub Cadet make sure that the metal parts have a durable rust-proof coating.

As a result, you can ride them in any weather condition without worrying about rust. Nevertheless, I don’t recommend rough uses.

Always try to take good care of your garden tractor, and you will get smooth cutting all the time.

8. After Service and Warranty

In terms of customer service, I have seen some good feedback about John Deere but can’t say the same about Cub Cadet.

There are good and bad in both brands, and the aftersales service depends a lot on the dealer.

Now, there is a difference in their product warranty. Cub Cadet is offering 4 years of warranty without giving the hour condition.

What I mean is that you don’t have to consider how many hours it has run to calculate the remaining warranty period.

Another big advantage is that the frame and front axle of the Cub Cadet XT3 GSX have 5 years of warranty.

On the other hand, John Deere also offers a 4-year warranty but they include a 500-hour time limit.

And the warranty claim is valid for whichever condition comes first.

Is Cub Cadet as Good as John Deere?

Yes, Cub Cadet is as good as the lawnmowers or tractors manufactured by John Deere. I like the performance of Cub Cadet’s EFI engines.

Reliable performance and enough power to perform heavy-duty tasks are the main reasons people love Cub Cadet lawnmowers.

Having fuel-efficient EFI engines can save roughly up to $500 in gasoline every year.

According to some users, Cub Cadet mowers last up to 3000 hours without showing any major issue.

Whether it is for commercial use or residential use, you can rely on both Cub Cadet and John Deere.

Who Makes Cub Cadet Engines?

The same company that owns the Cub Cadet brand makes engines for their lawnmower and tractor models; MTD Products is the name of the company.

MTD has its origin in Valley City, Ohio. After acquiring this famous brand MTD Products started making engines for Cub Cadets.

Their fuel-efficient EFI engines are appreciated across the industry. The brand also uses Kohler engines in some of its products.

Who Makes John Deere Engines?

Kawasaki, Yanmar, and Briggs & Stratton are the name of the manufacturers who make engines for John Deere.

When it comes to compact utility tractors, Yanmar is the name you will hear most. Over 40 years of partnership between JD and Yanmar has been fruitful.

Over the years, the company has perfected the performance of its diesel engines ensuring high power and reliable operation.

Cub Cadet XT3 GSX or John Deere X500: Which One to Choose? (The Verdict)

From the Cub Cadet XT3 GSX vs John Deere X500 comparison above, it is clear that JD X500 should be the first choice for those who have a large yard.

And, John Deere has a better engine with more accurate power and fuel efficiency.

Though the initial cost is higher, the price would seem reasonable once you consider the money it saves over the years.

Those who have smaller yards with tight corners and less time to spend on maintenance should go with Cub Cadet XT3. Also, it costs less.

Related Posts: